Member-only story
AI Still Needs You, Too
Why does using a GPT feel like cheating?
Using a GPT model to complete tasks can feel like “cheating” in the traditional way that we understand cheating. Webster’s dictionary defines cheating as:
1: to deprive of something valuable by the use of deceit or fraud
2: to influence or lead by deceit, trick, or artifice
3: to elude or thwart by or as if by outwitting
Let’s look at that first definition up-close.
“To deprive of something valuable” describes a transaction — or the absence of one — in which some value was supposed to be delivered, and it wasn’t. When we think of the value of written documents, we often think of the effort and the time spent writing as the object of value1. But there’s another object of value going on just under the surface, one that we might not see quite as fast: the thinking behind the effort.
To recognize the thinking behind the effort, we have to step back and examine some properties of the object we’re creating. We need to identify what result it’s being used to drive towards, and what context we need that result in. We also need to know what an unacceptable result might look like so that we can prevent it. Stepping back like this makes it easier to recognize the under-the-surface thinking going on.
Key touchpoint: Identify the goal of the output
What do you want to use this output for? Some commonly cited use cases include college admissions essays, website copy, and marketing content — with the goals of demonstrating a prospective student’s fitness for the university to which they’re applying, helping users navigate a website and get appropriate information, and educating potential customers about a business’s offerings. Your goals are likely to be different from any of these. Before prompting the GPT model, identify what you want it to do. This is a key touchpoint for human contribution in using AI. If you were meeting with a person to talk about this topic, what would you want to walk away with? It’s okay to take charge here and set the agenda. In fact, it adds value when you do.
